Years ago in Glamour magazine I read an article on Clinique's Lucky Penny eyeshadow. It was supposed to give the wearer a "bedroom eye" effect, something that looked gorgeous but didn't scream "I'm wearing makeup!" Well, I don't know if it does all of that... but it's still really pretty. :)
Clinique's Colour Surge Eye Shadow Super Shimmer (don't let that scare you off... it's not that shimmery... and they have two other versions - matte and soft shimmer) retail for $14.50 and come in pretty silver, mirrored compacts that hold .07 oz of product and a really nice, sturdy sponge applicator.
Undereye concealer: Garnier Nutritioniste Skin Renew Anti-Dark Circle Roller
Undereye powder: None
Lid color: Clinique Lucky Penny
Highlight: Clinique Buff
Eyeliner: Clinique Cream Shaper in Chocolate Lustre
Mascara: Maybelline Full 'n Soft in Dark Brown